Like so many other first generation Filipino’s in America, my parents immigrated to the United States in hopes of a better life. They studied hard in school, motivated by their poor economic upbringing to support their family back home, and create a new prosperous life in the United States. I am eternally grateful for the choices they’ve made and the opportunities they’ve provided for me. So when I came across this article first in the San Francisco Chronicle then on USA Today, it struck a profound chord that rings true in not just my life but also for every other Filipino who lives in the U.S.: The choice to stay and support a country, or move and support your family is a constant decision being made by thousands of Filipino’s graduating from college every year. Recent economic reports state that 70% of the nation’s economy is supported by overseas workers. Elmer Jacinto is one of them.
Once upon a time, Elmer Jacinto was his nation’s most promising young doctor. But doctors in the Philippines are not well paid, and so he boarded a plane to America.
To make more money. To become … a nurse.
Elmer Jacinto’s case isn’t new by any means, but it sparks debate in the Philippines and most developing Second and Third world nations. If you were to put me in either camp, opportunity versus nationalism, I would definitely take opportunity. In the case of my parents, they afforded me the opportunity to choose what I want to eat, where I want to go to school, and give me the choices, they worked so hard to achieve when they were younger. And to this day they give back to their homeland, in ways they would have been unable to do, if they remained in the Philippines.
Recently they went to their hometown, San Nicolas in the Philippines, for a medical mission, to provide, health care services and gifts to their hometown. I created a video of the recent event. Rather than proving the point on either side of the debate, this is an example of both opportunity and nationalism, community and pride, compassion and love. It is an example of what hard working people with hearts even bigger giving back to the country they left. Opportunity abroad eventually leading to opportunity in the country they left.
5 Comments to “The Filipino Debate: Opportunity versus Nationalism”
Tita wrote:
Great post. I think any form of nationalism can be both overrated and dangerous (see: current climate in the red states). While it’s important to preserve culture and some tradition, I don’t necessarily think that means remaining in a place that doesn’t give hard-working people a fighting chance. Props to your parents, and to you!
Posted on 05-Mar-07 at 3:36 pm | Permalink
mel wrote:
Thanks for the post, Genghis.
Posted on 08-Mar-07 at 3:49 pm | Permalink
8 Asians » “Desperate Housewives” clip infuriates Filipino Americans wrote:
[...] the United States. I touched upon this in a previous entry a few months ago, in a blog entry about Opportunity vs. Nationalism. The writers, in one slight to seem witty and comedic at the expense of hardworking men and women, [...]
Posted on 03-Oct-07 at 2:04 pm | Permalink
xyrwyn wrote:
great post. i have parents and grandparents as well who emigrated to the United States for greener pastures. (though i was born and raised in the Philippines) and the whole push and pull versus to leave for your family or stay for your country always strike a cord in the deepes of hearstring of Filipinos.
as for Emilio Jacinto, i do not judge him. as a nurse myself, i understand the opportunities given by this profession in this country. I applaud him for his earnest and pure intentions.
what do you think of the other side of the spectrum? of people who are already in the United States but opted to study Medical School in the Philippines?
just a thought.
Posted on 20-Oct-07 at 11:40 pm | Permalink
8Asians.com » Nurses from the Philippines face charges after quitting jobs: An Asian American/Asian Canadian Blog wrote:
[...] to become nurses in the United States, and most leave for the United States to earn more money. Some are doctors in the Philippines that leave to become nurses in search of better pay. There has been a nursing shortage in the US [...]
Posted on 18-Jan-08 at 12:08 pm | Permalink
Post a Comment