8 Asians

  • About us
  • Write for 8Asians
  • Podcast
  • Events
Meet the 8Asians: LianneMeet the 8Asians: Lianne
An Asian Girl’s Definition of HerselfAn Asian Girl’s Definition of Herself
Election 2012: Asian Americans Voter Turnout Declined from 2008 and Lowest Amongst All RacesElection 2012: Asian Americans Voter Turnout Declined from 2008 and Lowest Amongst All Races
The Death of The Two USC Chinese Students: Whose Fault Is It?The Death of The Two USC Chinese Students: Whose Fault Is It?

“Merantau” Indonesian Martial Arts Movie Review

By Tina | Thursday, April 12, 2012 | 4 Comments

In Merantau, Yuda (Iko Uwais), a young man from rural Indonesia trained in the martial art of silat harimau, heads off on a coming-of-age journey called a merantau. On his journey, he aims to go to the urban center of Jakarta and teach silat. After meeting orphans Adit (Yusuf Aulia) and Astri (Sisca Jessica), his path tangles inextricably with that of an underground slave trade ring, and his merantau quickly turns ugly.

When watching martial arts films, there is a range from the stylistic combat to straight up brutal and bloody violence. Too stylistic and you’ve got something that’s more ballet than martial arts; too brutal and bloody, and you’ve got something that just looks like a butcher house on the big screen. The film Merantau strikes a good balance between the two extremes, and the story is elegantly executed, too. More after the jump.

With any action film, there’s always the difficulty of integrating the action with the story, and most action and martial arts films tend to be more heavy on the action than the story. The action in this film not only struck a good balance between the stylistic and the brutal, it also integrated very nicely into the execution of the plot. The protagonist Yuda is strong and skilled, but not invulnerable. He’s noble but still inexperienced in the ways of the world, his naivete is both his weakness and his greatest strength. As the story progresses, it leans towards being hackneyed but never crosses that line, delivering a tale that is not full of dramatic twists but is clear, cogent, and heartfelt and substantiated with a lot of realistic consequences and honest emotion, somewhat in the style of the Rocky series. Though it’s hard for me to judge the acting clearly since I don’t speak or understand Indonesian, overall, the expression of the characters’ hopes, pains, and worries definitely felt like they were coming from living and breathing human souls.

I had really watched this film as a preface for the movie The Raid: Redemption because that film is (1) a martial arts action film and (2) prominent Japanese American musician and activist Mike Shinoda of Linkin Park scored the soundtrack.

Expecting “Merantau” to be just another violent, heartless action film, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the production, martial arts highlights, and overall story telling, and not because I had low expectations (really). Hopefully, “The Raid” will be just as good or better, with some nice Shinoda beats as it’s underlying heartbeat.

Thanks for rating this! Now tell the world how you feel - Share this on Twitter and on Facebook.
(Nah, it's cool; just take me back.)
MOODTHINGY
How does this post make you feel?
  • Excited
  • Fascinated
  • Amused
  • Bored
  • Sad
  • Angry

Categories:

EntertainmentMoviesReviews
Tweet

NOTE: 8Asians.com is a community, and we thank you for being a part of it. While we welcome and appreciate differences in opinion, if you're rude or you're promoting spam, we have a right to edit or delete your comment. Read our comment policy for more information.

If you see a comment that violates the 8Asians.com comment policy, you may flag the comment by mousing over the comment and clicking "FLAG."

Facebook Comments (Beta)

  • csc3

    i’ve seen “the raid”, but not “merantau” (it’s on my netflix queue though). it’s a pretty kickass movie, i definitely recommend it.

    and it’s nice to see some indonesian movies internationally :)

  • http://twitter.com/chicaaventurosa Lintang Timur

    Merantau is totally different from The Raid. Merantau takes time for character development, but The Raid is very economic in explaining the characters, so they can focus more on action.  Merantau focuses on the basic moves and philosophy of silat (in the international version the scene where Yuda explains the philosophy of silat was cut). The Raid shows the brutal side of silat.

  • http://www.facebook.com/tinabot Tina Tsai

    Good to know. Thanks for the info! I saw Merantau on Netflix, so I’m sure I got the one with the explanation was cut. Not cool. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/tinabot Tina Tsai

    Absolutely! Gotta find time to go watch “the raid” in theater, but I’ll catch it on bluray or stream if I don’t get to the theater in time.

 
Google
Custom Search
Advertise on 8Asians
Recent Posts
  • Chef Ming Tsai & White House Executive Chef Cook Healthy for American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month
  • Meet the 8Asians: Nithin
  • Asian American Commercial Watch: Ace Hardware Neighbors
  • Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)
  • An Asian Girl’s Definition of Herself
  • 8Asians Vlog from Lianne: Reverse Culture Shock
  • Giveaway: ‘Hangover 3′ Prize Package
Recent Comments
  • Don: Never been to Ace Hardware and I find more good deals and selection from Home Depot and Lowes. I find other good hardware tools deals... – Asian American Commercial Watch: Ace Hardware Neighbors
  • LTE2: "Low profile, make money, rise to hidden elite status" . You can run but you can not hide. The left employs cash sniffers and they... – Election 2012: Asian Americans Voter Turnout Declined from 2008 and Lowest Amongst All Races
  • Tina Tsai: LOL nice – Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)
  • A_Lee: Facebook is interesting because it's a more impulsive, less filtered medium, and lets you see what's right below the surface. Are these women crazy? No,... – An Asian Girl's Definition of Herself
  • A_Lee: I don't know how groundbreaking this is...he's a disheveled genius with unkempt hair and a week of stubble who has a messy house and enjoys... – Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)

APA Events

  • Feb 21: (San Jose, CA) New Stories from the Edge of Asia: This/That
  • Apr 26: (New York, NY) Front Row: Chinese American Designers
  • May 2: (San Francisco, CA) underCurrents & the Quest for Space
  • May 23: (San Jose, CA) Sake San Jose 2013
  • May 23: (San Francisco, CA) Asian Art Museum: Terracotta Warriors Private Tour & Dinner
  • Jun 1: (San Francisco, CA) Northern California Soy and Tofu Festival 2013
  • Jun 1: (San Francisco, CA) Asian American Bone Marrow Registry Registration Drive – 2013 Soy and Tofu Festival
  • Jun 6: (San Jose, CA) Questions from the Sky: New work from Hung Liu
Add Your Event
www.8asians.com

Staff and Contributors

  • Editors
  • Jocelyn "Joz" Wang

    Editor-in-chief/CEO
  • Moye Ishimoto

    Editor-at-large
  • Contributors
  • John L.

    LATEST POST: Chef Ming Tsai & White House Executive Chef Cook Healthy for American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month
  • Shako Liu

    LATEST POST: LAAPFF 2013: Mix-cultural Asians Find Their Roots
  • Tina Tsai

    LATEST POST: Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)
  • Tim Chiu

    LATEST POST: Behind the Smoke and Mirrors of Chinese Superstition
  • Jeff S.

    LATEST POST: The “it’s ok” Campaign Counters Stigma of Mental Illness
  • akrypti

    LATEST POST: Meet the 8Asians: Nithin
  • Koji Steven Sakai

    LATEST POST: Five Non-Asian Asians
View all Authors

Other Links

  • Get your very own 8Asians merchandise here!
Advertise | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook | Tumblr | Privacy Policy