8 Asians

  • About us
  • Write for 8Asians
  • Podcast
  • Events
Meet the 8Asians: LianneMeet the 8Asians: Lianne
Hate Map: Tweets Negatively Referring to “Chink”Hate Map: Tweets Negatively Referring to “Chink”
An Asian Girl’s Definition of HerselfAn Asian Girl’s Definition of Herself
8Asians Vlog from Lianne: Reverse Culture Shock8Asians Vlog from Lianne: Reverse Culture Shock

Thomas Beatie: “Pregnant-Again” Man, Once a Filipino

By Mitsuru | Friday, June 12, 2009 | 4 Comments

pregnant man Thomas Beatie: Pregnant Again Man, Once a FilipinoSo I had heard a while ago that Thomas Beatie — a celebrity transman — is a mixie much like myself. He too has a white mama, an Asian daddy, and originally, an Asian surname. He too was born with all the plumbing to make and be pregnant with a baby. He too made the decision to get folks to recognize him as male. So I get the whole need to change your gender thing. However, I’m not sure why he changed his name to something rid of all associations to his Filipino heritage. I too had the option to change my name to rid myself of my Asian ethnic associations, however, I didn’t based on the fact that so often trans folks of colour are told they are doing a white thing by being trans. As if the gender binaries of male and female were a universal thing, common and rigidly adhered to in every culture.

I wanted to keep my Asian association when renaming myself, to let people know that just because I’m trans doesn’t mean I’m white. There is a rich history of third gender or other wise non-male and non-female specific people within many cultures, including pre-Spanish Philippines. The rich history includes these societies valuing these people specifically because they are outside the norm of gender. Often times, folks like this would be held in high regard, chosen for positions of spiritual power and authority. However, rigid reforms in gender occurring in the white west, coupled with the need to topple indigenous authority figures influenced European colonizers to seek out and destroy these people. Violent and strategic colonization means that history validating Thomas’s and my trans experience as Asian genderf*ckers now is hard to come by. Transphobia is rampant in former colonized places, as a legacy of colonialism.

And now, because of this erased history, it is our very Asianness that is often used against us to make transphobic and racist comments: “Oh it must be hard with your Baachan more so than on your mom’s side,” “Hey, we don’t do that kind of freaky shit, we’re Asian.” Which makes me sad. Maybe it doesn’t make Thomas as sad as me, what with now two little ones to worry about, not to mention his book tour and the other burdens that fame and fortune bring.

Thanks for rating this! Now tell the world how you feel - Share this on Twitter and on Facebook.
(Nah, it's cool; just take me back.)
MOODTHINGY
How does this post make you feel?
  • Excited
  • Fascinated
  • Amused
  • Bored
  • Sad
  • Angry

Categories:

Current EventsLGBTObservations
Tweet

NOTE: 8Asians.com is a community, and we thank you for being a part of it. While we welcome and appreciate differences in opinion, if you're rude or you're promoting spam, we have a right to edit or delete your comment. Read our comment policy for more information.

If you see a comment that violates the 8Asians.com comment policy, you may flag the comment by mousing over the comment and clicking "FLAG."

Facebook Comments (Beta)

  • Cat_D

    Great post, Mitsuru. I can relate with the last bit. I want to thank 8Asians.com for having such diverse guest writers and for welcoming and sharing often unheard voices within the AA community. *thumbs up!*

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Efren-Bose/758823141 Efren Bose

    Mitsuru: thanks for the post and hope you become a regular poster for 8Asians!

    i think there is that mistaken belief that being queer or LGBT is being white, especially by people (especially of color) who aren’t aware of how different sexualities and genders existed precolonial/pre-Christian times, and it wasn’t a big deal. personally, i’m proud of being queer and Filipino and refuse to make any “choices” among my gender, sexuality and cultural background, even if i am a relatively boring gay-identified bio-boy who’s also Filipino American.

    it kinda annoys me that he’s calling himself a “pregnant man” since it seems that he’s milking the supposed weirdness of it all (i guess since most people aren’t used to seeing transmen, much less ones who decide to become pregnant), but if anything it shows that there are many different ways to show that gender isn’t just strictly male or female. i had no idea that he was mixed either.

  • Pingback: Thomas Beatie is Asian! Reclaiming Trans Histories of Colour at Racialicious - the intersection of race and pop culture

  • http://www.facebook.com/SitiNorbariaSally Sally Tan

    Read this!

 
Google
Custom Search
Advertise on 8Asians
Recent Posts
  • R.I.P. Lieutenant Sulu, in ‘Star Trek Into Darkness’
  • Hate Map: Tweets Negatively Referring to “Chink”
  • I am South Indian, Hindu, Buddhist, American… But Am I Asian, Too?
  • Chef Ming Tsai & White House Executive Chef Cook Healthy for American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month
  • Meet the 8Asians: Nithin
  • Asian American Commercial Watch: Ace Hardware Neighbors
  • Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)
Recent Comments
  • Don: I saw it last week and like the movie, but yes John Cho's Sulu gets less screen time than the last film. However he is... – R.I.P. Lieutenant Sulu, in 'Star Trek Into Darkness'
  • happyappa: He/she also: 1) blames the victims 2) believes "colorblindness" solves everything 3) thinks the only way a show can be diverse is if it has... – HBO's Girls Reminds Us That The Only Ones Who Matter Are White
  • zdrav: Are you saying that HBO is the white equivalent of BET? Don't you see how problematic that is? – HBO's Girls Reminds Us That The Only Ones Who Matter Are White
  • EastAsianNationalist: I'm actually surprised there's so much more "chink" than there is "wetback" or "spic. Could the results be skewed by people using "chink" in non-offensive... – Hate Map: Tweets Negatively Referring to "Chink"
  • EastAsianNationalist: Well in Britain they'd call you Asian and no one would bat an eye. Here in North America, Asian usually refers to East Asians... – I am South Indian, Hindu, Buddhist, American… But Am I Asian, Too?

APA Events

  • Feb 21: (San Jose, CA) New Stories from the Edge of Asia: This/That
  • Apr 26: (New York, NY) Front Row: Chinese American Designers
  • May 2: (San Francisco, CA) underCurrents & the Quest for Space
  • Jun 1: (San Francisco, CA) Northern California Soy and Tofu Festival 2013
  • Jun 1: (San Francisco, CA) Asian American Bone Marrow Registry Registration Drive – 2013 Soy and Tofu Festival
  • Jun 6: (San Jose, CA) Questions from the Sky: New work from Hung Liu
  • Jun 15: (Los Angeles, CA) V3con 2013: V3 Digital Media Conference presented by AAJA-LA
  • Jun 19: (Aptos, CA) LYF Camp 2013: “Choose Your Own Adventure”
Add Your Event
www.8asians.com

Staff and Contributors

  • Editors
  • Jocelyn "Joz" Wang

    Editor-in-chief/CEO
  • Moye Ishimoto

    Editor-at-large
  • Contributors
  • John L.

    LATEST POST: Chef Ming Tsai & White House Executive Chef Cook Healthy for American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month
  • Tina Tsai

    LATEST POST: Lucy Liu, Hollywood Asian Stereotypes, and “Elementary” (my dear Watson)
  • Shako Liu

    LATEST POST: LAAPFF 2013: Mix-cultural Asians Find Their Roots
  • Koji Steven Sakai

    LATEST POST: Hate Map: Tweets Negatively Referring to “Chink”
  • akrypti

    LATEST POST: Meet the 8Asians: Nithin
  • Tim Chiu

    LATEST POST: Behind the Smoke and Mirrors of Chinese Superstition
  • Jeff S.

    LATEST POST: The “it’s ok” Campaign Counters Stigma of Mental Illness
View all Authors

Other Links

  • Get your very own 8Asians merchandise here!
Advertise | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook | Tumblr | Privacy Policy