The United States Vs. Takaichi Sakai: Crimes, Part 1 of 5

By Koji Steven | Tuesday, July 12, 2011 | 11 Comments

Thanks for visiting 8Asians, a blog about Asian American issues. If you find this interesting, subscribe to the RSS feed, visit our Facebook Page or add us on Twitter!

family portrait 432x600 The United States Vs. Takaichi Sakai: Crimes, Part 1 of 5 He burned sensitive files while working for a foreign government. He said that he was not willing to fight for the United States and would not give up his allegiance to a foreign power during a time of war. He renounced his American citizenship. Who was this enemy of the United States?

He was my grandfather on my dad’s side. Having died before I was born, he was and has always been an enigma to me. My Aunt doesn’t remember her father being anti-American. To her, he was a true patriot. Any suggestion otherwise doesn’t fit in with how she chooses to remember him.

Based on his actions though, most would call him a traitor. I want to believe, like my Aunt, that he was a “good” American and that he was forced to make decisions that only made him look disloyal.

Over the last six years, I have been doing research on my grandfather. Recently, a wonderful National Archives researcher helped me “find” his FBI file. In the documents, my grandfather finally had a chance to tell me what happened and why he made the decisions that he did. In this five-part series, I will use primary documents and my grandfather’s words as much as possible. Where needed, I will add historical context to help understand the story. In the end, I believe my Grandfather’s World War II experience is the All-American story of what happens when you “look” like the enemy.

My grandfather’s name was Takaichi Sakai. He was born on August 10, 1903 in Pahala, Hawaii. His father had immigrated from Japan during the late 1880s, making him a Nisei, or second generation Japanese American. He worked as a clerk for the Japanese consulate’s office until December 6, 1941.

The FBI Intelligence report I found in the National Archives in my grandmother’s file (Sato Sakai) laid out the case against my grandfather:

(That might be difficult to read, so let me transcribe it for you below)

August 11, 1942

Reference is made to your request for a name check on Sato Sakai. This individual is the wife of Takaichi Sakai. Her husband was associated with the Young Men’s Buddhist Association and has also worked as a clerk in the Japanese Consulate in Honolulu. On one occasion in 1937 her husband and another individual seized and attempted to manhandle a United States Photographer, who was assigned to observe the activities of a Japanese Oil tanker on its visit to Hawaii. They attempted to seize photographs taken by this photographer. It was alleged that her husband was more of an old time Japanese than a Hawaiian-born Japanese. He was reported to be extremely pro-Japanese and Anti-American in sentiment. Her husband was taken into custody by the military authorities under a warrant authorized by the Secretary of War on October 3, 1942. He was afforded a hearing before an Internee Hearing Board, and it was brought out while before the board that her husband while working for the consulate was suspicious of the activities of several other employees but did not divulge this information to the proper authority. He admitted that around August 1, 1941, many papers from the files of the consulate were burned, and he admitted that the clerks were paid for it and told not to tell anyone that they had been burned. The board recommended that he be interned, and the military governor, at Honolulu, Hawaii, on February 12, 1943, after a review of the evidence and the recommendation of the board, ordered that her husband be interned for the duration of the war. On February 24, 1943, however, the Military Governor ordered that he be released from internment and transferred to a relocation center on the Mainland. (Signed m.b.)

Unfortunately, my grandfather does not address any of these charges specifically in any of the documents I have found. However, in the FBI file, the FBI interrogated him and was unable to find anything against him:

In the end, it is difficult to say how much he did or didn’t know while working for the Japanese consulate. However, I believe that if they had any strong evidence of true espionage or treason against him, they would have happily convicted him in a real court of law.

The United States Vs. Takaichi Sakai: No No, Part 2 of 5

Categories:

DiscriminationHistory

NOTE: 8Asians.com is a community, and we thank you for being a part of it. While we welcome and appreciate differences in opinion, if you're rude or you're promoting spam, we have a right to edit or delete your comment. Read our comment policy for more information.

If you see a comment that violates the 8Asians.com comment policy, you may flag the comment by mousing over the comment and clicking "FLAG."

Facebook Comments (Beta)

http://www.erniehsiung.com/ Ernie H.

Looking forward to your series, Koji.
moye

@Ernie H. I hope Part 5 is titled: THE BIRTH OF KOJI.
gasagasagirl

This is amazing, Koji. It’s like the unraveling of a mystery, you history detective!
http://www.8Asians.com/ jozjozjoz

@KojiStevenSakai Thanks for sharing your family history and the results of your awesome sleuthing, Koji!
yu888

Awesome. Looking forward to the next 4 parts.
Reechard

Intriguing…interested to see where this goes.
kunlao21

If this topic is of further interest, I HGHLY recommend:

“American Inquisition: The Hunt for Japanese American Disloyalty in World War II” by eric L. Muller

It’s a highly detailed account of the Eisee/Neisee Citizens’ experiences with regard to how they were viewed/acted upon by the Federal Govt, Military, courts and citizens at the time. It’s at a local library or downloadable audio. I’ve read/listended to both.

Looking forward to Koji’s articles.
Pingback: The United States Vs. Takaichi Sakai: No No, Part 2 of 5 | Discrimination | 8Asians.com
http://me.mikelee.org/ mikeleeorg

This series is so damn fascinating and gripping. Major props for sharing all of this, man! It could make for a great movie or documentary. In fact, it reminds me a lot of “99 Years of Love: Japanese American” – though a lot more gritty and real (of course).

FYI to other readers: if you like this series, consider checking out “99 Years of Love” too:

http://www.culturalnews.com/?p=3182
Pingback: The Difference Between Internment Camps and Concentration Camps | Discrimination | 8Asians.com
Pingback: 70th Anniversary of the Signing of Executive Order 9066 | Discrimination | 8Asians.com

8 Asians