Excited
This past Friday, The Wall Street Journal had a book excerpt from Fat Envelope Frenzy: One Year, Five Promising Students and The Pursuit of the Ivy League Prize and one of the five students the book profiles is an Asian-American high school student named Felix Zhang. Zhang has always dreamed of going to Harvard, yet despite his very, very impressive academic and extracurricular credentials, he is worried that he will be discriminated against because he is Asian:
“On the surface, it might seem that Felix is a shoo-in for admission to Harvard. However, as an Asian American, Felix is also a member of a group that is overrepresented in the Harvard applicant pool, which could be a disadvantage in the admissions process. In the past two decades, selective colleges have been repeatedly accused of a bias against Asian Americans, and several students have gone so far as to file official complaints with the federal government at the Office for Civil Rights. No university has ever been convicted of discrimination, but an investigation into the admissions process at Harvard in the early 1990s uncovered a number of offensive remarks written by the staff in regard to Asian American candidates, including glib descriptions such as ‘he’s quiet and, of course, wants to be a doctor.’”
Obviously, this is a very sensitive topic amongst Asian-Americans. There has always been the myth of the model minority amongst Asian-Americans, but the racial categorization has always been a disservice for those Asians who come from lower-income families. I’m still a proponent of affirmative action for traditionally under-represented minorities, but I feel a tension when I know that with a “fixed” number of admission spots to the best universities in the nation, plenty of qualified student applicants will be rejected to their first choice. And this may disproportionately affect Asian-Americans more than any other racial group.
Instead of “racial profiling” applicants, the biggest factor influencing academic achievement I think is based on family income. One thing that I do admire about countries with one single entrance exam to be admitted for college and universities is that there is a clear criteria for admissions – scoring a certain score to be admitted. Though some countries, like Taiwan, are moving more towards the American model of college admissions – striving for more “diversity” – academically, as well as extracurricularly, since talent and intelligence (in all forms) is simply too difficult to measure in a single exam.
How does this post make you feel?
- Fascinated
- Amused
- Bored
- Sad
- Angry
NOTE: 8Asians.com is a community, and we thank you for being a part of it. While we welcome and appreciate differences in opinion, if you're rude or you're promoting spam, we have a right to edit or delete your comment. Read our comment policy for more information.
If you see a comment that violates the 8Asians.com comment policy, you may flag the comment by mousing over the comment and clicking "FLAG."
Well, most college admissions in the United States is subjective, i.e. - not based on a specific criteria of GPA and test scores. So I guess one could argue that "deserve" is also subjective.
Well, most college admissions in the United States is subjective, i.e. - not based on a specific criteria of GPA and test scores. So I guess one could argue that "deserve" is also subjective.
How do you define "deserve" to get in? Top programs like the one John attended accept far fewer applicants than "deserve" to get in based on their academic and personal qualifications.
How do you define "deserve" to get in? Top programs like the one John attended accept far fewer applicants than "deserve" to get in based on their academic and personal qualifications.
re: MBAs. well John, you may have been the lucky one. someone always gets in. but does the same proportion get in that deserve to get in?
=)
You gotta look at the big picture. not just your n of 1.
re: MBAs. well John, you may have been the lucky one. someone always gets in. but does the same proportion get in that deserve to get in?
=)
You gotta look at the big picture. not just your n of 1.
Ivy Leaguer - while what you say may be true, unless there is solid evidence of his plagiarized essay, I'd rather not have people speculate on this. As for Zhang cheating on his girlfriend - well, that's reality if it is true. Note: I do not know Felix Zhang.
Ivy Leaguer - while what you say may be true, unless there is solid evidence of his plagiarized essay, I'd rather not have people speculate on this. As for Zhang cheating on his girlfriend - well, that's reality if it is true. Note: I do not know Felix Zhang.
I know this kid. He's actually a bit of an ass. He plagiarized the essay that got him into Harvard and won him some lofty scholarship. The school found out but he and his mom pleaded their way out.
Also, there's mad rumors about him cheating on a girlfriend with two other girls.
I know this kid. He's actually a bit of an ass. He plagiarized the essay that got him into Harvard and won him some lofty scholarship. The school found out but he and his mom pleaded their way out.
Also, there's mad rumors about him cheating on a girlfriend with two other girls.
David - I am aware of "The Price of Admission" - I just haven't gotten around to buying or borrowing it to read. As for top MBA programs, I went to one... not sure what you are talking about.
David - I am aware of "The Price of Admission" - I just haven't gotten around to buying or borrowing it to read. As for top MBA programs, I went to one... not sure what you are talking about.
Read "The Price of Admission" by Daniel Golden, who is a pulitzer prize winning writer for the WSJ. It basically tells you how the system, which was originally instituted to discriminate against Jews, is now being used to discriminate against Asian-Americans. The parallels are uncanny, with all the same stereotypes used for both sets of minorities ("quiet", "unathletic", "weak", "not leadership material", "all the same", etc.). Are Asian-Americans discriminated against, yes. Top universities will never publicly release statistics so that they can hide behind a wall of secrecy. The discrimination is even worse at top MBA programs - but don't even get me started on that.
Read "The Price of Admission" by Daniel Golden, who is a pulitzer prize winning writer for the WSJ. It basically tells you how the system, which was originally instituted to discriminate against Jews, is now being used to discriminate against Asian-Americans. The parallels are uncanny, with all the same stereotypes used for both sets of minorities ("quiet", "unathletic", "weak", "not leadership material", "all the same", etc.). Are Asian-Americans discriminated against, yes. Top universities will never publicly release statistics so that they can hide behind a wall of secrecy. The discrimination is even worse at top MBA programs - but don't even get me started on that.
the UC system has side-stepped the affirmative action issue by admissions based on income levels, which I think is a diplomatic way of admitting students without having to base the decision on race or ethnicity.
the UC system has side-stepped the affirmative action issue by admissions based on income levels, which I think is a diplomatic way of admitting students without having to base the decision on race or ethnicity.
Trackbacks
Custom Search
Recent Posts
- Jennifer Yuh Nelson Wins Annie Award for Kung Fu Panda 2
- Report Reveals APA Gay & Lesbian Organizations Only Receive 0.7% Of Available LGBT Funding
- What I Learned From Posting A Dragon Lady Personal Ad
- Hard Boiled Egg Mold for Bento Decoration
- Is Classical Music Alive For Long?
- VIRAL LIKE SARS: North Korean Accordion Players Perform a-ha’s Take On Me
- California Shark Fin Soup Suppliers Sue State Over Ban
Recent Comments
- : "The only people left keeping classical music alive are Asian Americans and older adults. Eventually if classical music does die off in Western countries, it... – Is Classical Music Alive For Long?
- : "It has been said that playing an instrument as a child is the greatest predictor of concert attendance as an adult. " Not for me,... – Is Classical Music Alive For Long?
- : @TinaTsai I had a class that was like that; where the students would come together and discuss certain topics and end in some consensus. The... – How Standardized Tests Stunt the Intellectual Growth of Asian American Students
- : This is equal parts enraging and chilling. I did a long reaction here. – Pete Hoekstra's Offensive Anti-Asian Super Bowl Ad
- : @dragonrider0ne Thanks for the vote of confidence ^_^ When you say "been through the grind", I have to say, it was quite a grind. Everything... – How Standardized Tests Stunt the Intellectual Growth of Asian American Students
APA Events
Feb 10: (Los Angeles, CA) CAUSE: Women in Power Annual Luncheon
Feb 15: (Seattle, WA) Pork Filled Players Enter The Year of the Dragon Spam*O*Rama
Feb 16: Adam WarRock and Kirby Krackle: West Cost Tour Dates!!!
Feb 16: (New York, NY) Amar Chitra Katha: Monica Ferrell, Chitra Ganesh, Keshni Kashyap, and Himanshu “Heems” Suri of Das Racist
Feb 17: (Los Angeles, CA) All My Sons
Feb 18: (Stanford, CA) Stanford’s 16th Listen to the Silence Conference- Feb 18: (San Francisco, CA) NAAAP-SF Lunar New Year Gala 2012
Feb 25: (Los Angeles, CA) Past Present I Future Imperatives: Queer Space Time
Staff and Contributors
- Editors
- Ernie Hsiung - Founder, Editor-in-Chief
- Moye Ishimoto - Co-Editor, Editorial
- Joz Wang - Co-Editor, PR & APA Outreach
[...] China. It highlights the education at small liberal arts colleges, which are much less known than the Ivy’s. Maybe there should be a book in the U.S. for Asian American parents too on this [...]